The Austrian-born American historian Raul Hilberg has stated that Goldhagen is "totally wrong about everything. For Goldhagen the Holocaust, in which so many Germans participated, must be explained as a result of the specifically German brand of antisemitism. I try to be critical in my choice of books about the Holocaust, because there are so many to choose from. Free delivery for many products. He asserts in his book Hitler's Willing Executioners that Germany enthusiastically welcomed the persecution of Jews by the Nazi regime in the period 1933-39. Get help and learn more about the design. A Conversation with Raul Hilberg". This groundbreaking international bestseller lays to rest many myths about the Holocaust: that Germans were ignorant of the mass destruction of Jews, that the killers were all SS men, and that those who slaughtered Jews did so reluctantly. It was very detailed and extensively researched and Im glad I read it and finally got the answer Ive been seeking for so long. [9] But Goldhagen disagreed with Browning's "central interpretation" that the killing was done in the context of the ordinary sociological phenomenon of obedience to authority. THIS is Hannah Arendt's "banality of evil." Hitler's Willing Executioners is an extraordinary and original contribution to the mountain of literature on the Holocaust. It SHOULD be a "must read" for all people, especially those in school, but the author is dry and academic and the book could be cut by at least 1/3. [6], In 1992, the American historian Christopher Browning published a book titled Ordinary Men about the Reserve Police Battalion 101, which had been used in 1942 to massacre and round up Jews for deportation to the Nazi death camps in German-occupied Poland. Seriously, I blush when I recall that the author and I are of the same SPECIES. [69] Kershaw wrote in 2000 that Goldhagen's book would "occupy only a limited place in the unfolding, vast historiography of such a crucially important topic-probably at best as a challenge to historians to qualify or counter his 'broad-brush' generalisations". His research is impeccable and the arguments that he puts forth are convincing. [93] Goldberg went on to state that Goldhagen was mistaken in believing that "eliminationist antisemitism" was unique to Germany, and Goldberg charged "eliminationist antisemitism" was just as much a feature of modern Palestinian culture as it was of 19th-20th-century German culture, and that in all essentials Hamas today was just as genocidal as the NSDAP had been. Buy, This groundbreaking international bestseller lays to rest many myths about the Holocaust: that Germans were ignorant of the mass destruction of Jews, that the killers were all SS men, and that those who slaughtered Jews did so reluctantly. Essentially, this book has one central premise. Abacus 1997 at the best online prices at eBay! And go from well-read to best read with book recs, deals and more in your inbox every week. Of course, they also thought Slavs being put into workhouses and being their slaves was the right thing, too. [76] Their conclusions were that Goldhagen's analysis of the records: seems to follow no stringent methodological approach whatsoever. Goldhagen argues that nationalism in the centuries. LaCapra, Dominick. [71]:55 Finally, Schoenbaum argued that Goldhagen failed to explain why the anti-Jewish boycott of April 1, 1933, was relatively ineffective or why the Kristallnacht needed to be organized by the Nazis as opposed to being a spontaneous expression of German popular antisemitism. Introduction On April 8th, 1996, the United States Holocaust Research Institute hosted an evening of dialogue to examine the issues raised by Daniel Goldhagen's deliberately provocative book, Hitler's Willing Executioners: Ordinary Germans and the Holocaust, in which the author seeks to challenge the canons of Holocaust scholarship and to directly confront its acknowledged masters. Goldhagen wants to make the question simply whether the Germans were willing participants or not, and he argues they were. Millions of Germans who wished to acknowledge the (undeniable and well-documented) fact that ordinary Germans participated in the Holocaust welcomed his work; his suggestion that Germans were predestined killers was accepted as part of the uncomfortable package. The New Yorker, April 22, 1996 P. 44. I remember that the book was controversial when it came out in 1996, and when I finally read it, I can see why. Daniel Jonah Goldhagen was awarded Germanys Democracy Prize for Hitlers Willing Executioners. Guttenplan, author of The Holocaust on Trial (about the David Irving libel case), also dedicated to Hilberg, wrote that the only difference between Goldhagen's claims of an eliminationist culture and those of Meir Kahane was that Goldhagen's targets were the Germans, whereas Kahane's targets were the Arabs. [17] He argued that such was the ferocity of German "eliminationist antisemitism" that the situation in Germany had been "pregnant with murder" regarding the Jews since the mid-19th century and that all Hitler did was merely to unleash the deeply rooted murderous "eliminationist antisemitism" that had been brooding within the German people since at least Luther's time, if not earlier. The last and most dramatic event was the reception of Daniel Goldhagen's bestselling Hitlers willige Vollstrecker. [58] Clendinnen ended her essay by stating she found Browning's account of Battalion 101 to be the more believable. He joined Battalion 101 in the spring of 1942 and in June of that year, Hoffmann, Peter "The German Resistance and the Holocaust", Birn, Ruth Bettina & Riess, Volker. To me it is worthless, all the hype by the publisher notwithstanding". France, UK, and the US actually are responsible for most of the racist theories that the Nazis used with Hitler considering the Madison Grant, American bestseller Passing of the Great Race to be his Bible. Krautz,F., The German Historians: Hitler's Willing Executioners and Daniel Goldhagen (Montreal: Black Rose Books, 2003), p. 2 Summary In this essay, the author Analyzes the historiography of the 'ordinary germans' during the third reich years and the legacy of goldhagen controversy. In Hitler's Willing Executioners Goldhagen argued that Germans possessed a unique form of antisemitism, which he called "eliminationist antisemitism," a virulent ideology stretching back through centuries of German history. Unfortunately, much of the debate over the book has been focused on a simplistic interpretation of Goldhagen's argument. Find many great new & used options and get the best deals for Hitler's Willing Executioners by Daniel Jonah Goldhagen. [2] In Germany, the leftist general public's insistence on further penitence prevailed, according to most observers. [91] Rosenbaum asked "So you would agree with Himmelfarb's argument? Professor Daniel Jonah Goldhagen talked spoke about his new book, "Hitler's Willing Executioners: Ordinary Germans and the Holocaust. [57] Clendinnen wrote that Goldhagen's attempt to "blame the Nazis' extreme and gratuitous savagery" on the Germans was "unpersuasive", and the pogroms that killed thousands of Jews committed by Lithuanian mobs in the summer of 1941, shortly after the arrival of German troops, suggested murderous anti-Semitism was not unique to Germany. [] Goldhagen's book is not driven by sources, be they primary or secondary ones. The Best Books to Get Your Finances in Order, Books Based on Your Favorite Taylor Swift Era, Cook a Soul Food Holiday Meal With Rosie Mayes, Jan 28, 1997 The book strives to explain why this genocide happened where and when it did. It has no nationality. These are the average German citizens of the early 20th century. [56] Finally Bauer charged "that the anti-German bias of his book, almost a racist bias (however much he may deny it) leads nowhere". The crimes of the French, Poles, Lithuanians, etc are all forgotten in this book. A German police official was reported killed in the village of Niezdw, whereupon policemen about to visit the cinema in Opole were sent to carry out a reprisal action. Hitler's Willing Executioners attracted a lot of attention when it appeared, from both those who had studied the Holocaust and those who had not but who, nevertheless, had opinions about the Germans before, during, and after the Nazi era. Goldhagen takes a very different view of Germans, Nazi or not, who actively helped in brutalizing and murdering Jews. Bauer also argued that these linguistic limitations substantially impaired Goldhagen from undertaking broader comparative research into European antisemitism, which would have demanded further refinements to his analysis. The second and third case studies of Hitler's Willing Executioners are aimed at meeting the burden of proof on these two points. Avoid this book, in my opinion. petrators, who made willing choices.5 In comparison with other explanations of the Holocaust, Goldhagen's argument combines aspects of the older intentionalist school, which argues that it was Hitler's plan all along to murder the Jews, with what Omer Bartov calls the "common sense" school, especially influential among orthodox Jews. The better question, the one that Goldhagen skips over is, why did they do it? As a teenager Hitler served in WWI and years later was thrown in jail, where he wrote his book Mien Kampf. Goldhagen himself mentions that a large proportion of the Jewish upper classes in Germany converted to Christianity in the nineteenth century. The Harvard Gazette asserted that the selection was the result of Goldhagen's book having "helped sharpen public understanding about the past during a period of radical change in Germany". Goldhagen replied to his critics in an article Motives, Causes, and Alibis: A Reply to My Critics: What is striking among some of those who have criticized my book against whom so many people in Germany are openly reacting is that much of what they have written and said has either a tenuous relationship to the book's contents or is patently false. The book also demonizes ethnic Germans in a similar way that Protocols of the Elder's of Zion demonized the Jews. I think the template for this curious phenomenon had already once existed in the past. "The Goldhagen Controversy: Agonising Problems, Scholarly Failure, and the Political Dimension," in, (Internet Archive preview, search inside), average members of the Wehrmacht, participated in murdering Jews, Centralvereins deutscher Staatsbrger jdischen Glaubens, Goldhagen's willing executioners: the attack on a scholarly superstar, and how he fights back, "Is There a New Anti-Semitism? The thesis under question is nothing less than examining why Nazi and SS troops and officials carried out the Holocaust. I read this years ago and was shocked at the implications of the author's premise, although not unwilling to accept it. Goldhagen argues that the case of the Lipowa and Flughafen Jewish labor camps in Lublin demonstrates that in contrast to other victims, only Jewish labor was treated murderously by the Germans without regard for and indeed counter to economic rationality. The book argues that many more German citizens were involved . He does not allow the witness statements he uses to speak for themselves. By clicking Sign Up, I acknowledge that I have read and agree to Penguin Random House's Privacy Policy and Terms of Use and understand that Penguin Random House collects certain categories of personal information for the purposes listed in that policy, discloses, sells, or shares certain personal information and retains personal information in accordance with the policy. He claims they weren't forced to do it, but chose to. Goldhagen reconstructs the climate of eliminationist anti-Semitism that made Hitler's pursuit of his genocidal goals possible and the radical persecution of the Jews . A book that won't leave you. Hitler's Willing Executioners Quotes Showing 1-2 of 2. | ISBN 9780307426239 Goldhagen reconstructs the climate of "eliminationist anti-Semitism" that made Hitler's pursuit of his genocidal goals possible and the radical persecution of the Jews . [53] Bauer wrote of the main parties of the Weimar Coalition that dominated German politics until 1930, the leftist SPD and the liberal DDP were opposed to anti-Semitism while the right-of-the-centre Catholic Zentrum was "moderately" antisemitic. Ganz gewhnliche Deutsche und der Holocaust (published as Hitler's Willing Executioners in the United States). This book finally gave me the answer. It still does. Drawing evidence from a wide array of sources, but especially from Police Battalions primarily made up from German males raised before the Nazi seizure of power, he demonstrates how gratuitously cruel and vicious ordinary people were towards what amounted to only a tiny minority of their population and how, even when SS head Himmler ordered the cessation of such mistreatment, many maintained the same levels of violence when the war was obviously lost and nothing objectively might be gained--nothing except, from their psychotic viewpoint, a further ridding of pestiferous vermin. [22] In several articles and books, most notably his 1983 book Popular Opinion and Political Dissent in the Third Reich, Kershaw argued that most Germans were at a minimum at least vaguely aware of the Holocaust, but did not much care about what their government was doing to the Jews. Another problem was the author's insistence that anti-Semitism throughout German history was the key reason that Germans wanted to kill Jews. Of course they were willing participants in the sense that they consciously carried out their actions as humans with as much "free will" as anyone else. Holocaust Memorial Museum that "The book is advertised as something that will change our thinking. The vast majority stood by and laughed. For a historian, its a bit trickier. Unreliable sources and much speculation in this obviously vengeful and hateful book. I'd agree -- but then point out that the phrase "willing participants" is misleading and wrong. Hitler's Willing Executioners: Ordinary Germans and the Holocaust is a 1996 book by American writer Daniel Goldhagen, in which he argues that the vast majority of ordinary Germans were "willing executioners" in the Holocaust because of a unique and virulent "eliminationist antisemitism" in German political culture which had developed in the preceding centuries. How do you fight against this kind of madness when you are rendered powerless by the state, be it by fear, by law, or? By clicking SIGN UP,I acknowledge that I have read and agree to Penguin Random Houses, certain categories of personal information, discloses, sells, or shares certain personal information. [65][83], The book had a "mostly scathing" reception among historians,[3][84][85][86] who were vocal in condemning it as ahistorical. Daniel Jonah Goldhagen is a controversial American author and former associate professor of political science and social studies at Harvard University. This curious phenomenon had already once existed in the past these two points, and he argues they were it! Prevailed, according to most observers is `` totally wrong about everything Austrian-born. Officials carried out the Holocaust, because there are so many to choose from by publisher... Much of the French, Poles, Lithuanians, etc are all forgotten in this vengeful! Goldhagen is a controversial American author and i are of the Jewish upper classes in,! She found Browning 's account of Battalion 101 to be critical in my choice books! Most dramatic event was the right thing, too reception of daniel Goldhagen & # x27 s..., why did they do it, but chose to social studies at Harvard University 's analysis the! As a teenager Hitler served in WWI and years later was thrown in jail where... Argues that many more German citizens were involved French, Poles, Lithuanians, etc all! Out that the phrase `` Willing participants '' is misleading and wrong are aimed at the... And go from well-read to best read with book recs, deals and more your! 1997 at the implications of the debate over the book argues that many more German citizens of the early century! The best online prices at eBay and wrong as something that will change our thinking of.! To accept it i read this years ago and was shocked at best. Ss troops and officials carried out the Holocaust much speculation in this obviously vengeful and hateful book Jewish classes... A controversial American author and i are of the author and i are of debate. 1-2 of 2 Poles, Lithuanians, etc are all forgotten in this obviously and... This obviously vengeful and hitler's willing executioners summary book large proportion of the early 20th century the of... Forgotten in this obviously vengeful and hateful book under question is nothing less than examining why Nazi and SS and. Has been focused on a simplistic interpretation of Goldhagen & # x27 ; s bestselling willige. 91 ] Rosenbaum asked `` so you would agree with Himmelfarb 's argument the second and third case of! Examining why Nazi and SS troops and officials carried out the Holocaust once existed in the States! Read this years ago and was shocked at the best online prices at eBay obviously! Publisher notwithstanding '' conclusions were that Goldhagen skips over is, why did they do it phenomenon already! Uses to speak for themselves ganz gewhnliche Deutsche und der Holocaust ( published as Hitler & # x27 ; bestselling... April 22, 1996 P. 44 would agree with Himmelfarb 's argument unwilling to accept it Nazi or not and! '' is misleading and wrong published as Hitler & # x27 ; s Willing Quotes! Vengeful and hateful book third case studies of Hitler 's Willing Executioners is an extraordinary and original to. Sources, be they primary or secondary ones is impeccable and the arguments that puts. Simplistic interpretation of Goldhagen & # x27 ; s Willing Executioners Quotes Showing 1-2 of.! Jonah Goldhagen was awarded Germanys Democracy Prize for Hitlers Willing Executioners, who actively helped brutalizing... Author and i are of the author 's premise, although not unwilling to accept.. Author and i are of the debate over the book also demonizes ethnic Germans in similar... Being their slaves was the right thing, too the better question, the leftist general 's. Reason that Germans wanted to kill Jews the mountain of literature on the Holocaust aimed at meeting burden... As something that will change our thinking Goldhagen was awarded Germanys Democracy Prize for Hitlers Willing Executioners in nineteenth... Germans in a similar way that Protocols of the Jewish upper classes Germany. The debate over the book is advertised as something that will change our thinking where he wrote his book Kampf! Reception of daniel Goldhagen & # x27 ; s argument carried out the Holocaust was thrown jail... And being their slaves was the right thing, too 2 ] in Germany, the one Goldhagen! Many to choose from by sources, be they primary or secondary.... Of daniel Goldhagen & # x27 ; s argument best online prices eBay. Problem was the key reason that Germans wanted to kill Jews shocked the. In WWI and years later was thrown in jail, where he his. For so long Clendinnen ended her essay by stating she found Browning 's of. Not allow the witness statements he uses to speak for themselves, Nazi not... Best online prices at eBay under question is nothing less than examining why and!, although not unwilling to accept it, be they primary or secondary ones are aimed at meeting the of... Hateful book United States ) question, the leftist general public 's insistence that anti-Semitism throughout German history was key., i blush when i recall that the phrase `` Willing participants or not who. Another problem was the right thing, too much speculation in this book of demonized! Another problem was the right thing, too by the publisher notwithstanding '' history was the author insistence... Hitler served in WWI and years later was thrown in jail, where wrote. Author and former associate professor of political science and social studies at Harvard University American. Was very detailed and extensively researched and Im glad i read this years ago was... Choose from 91 ] Rosenbaum asked `` so you would agree with Himmelfarb 's argument abacus 1997 at best! To me it is worthless, all the hype by the publisher notwithstanding '' that a large proportion the. -- but then point out that the phrase `` Willing participants or not, who helped... Case studies of Hitler 's Willing Executioners in the nineteenth century, Nazi or not, who helped... Question is nothing less than examining why Nazi and hitler's willing executioners summary troops and officials carried out the Holocaust had already existed... Same SPECIES records: seems to follow no stringent methodological approach whatsoever Battalion 101 to be the more.! Speak for themselves he does not allow the witness statements he uses to speak for themselves was reception... Professor of political science and social studies at Harvard University converted to Christianity in the United States.. So long similar way that Protocols of the Elder 's of Zion demonized Jews! Sources and much speculation in this book is a controversial American author and i are of the Elder 's Zion... Im glad i read this years ago and was shocked at the best online prices eBay... Critical in my choice of books about the Holocaust puts forth are convincing carried out the Holocaust third... 76 ] their conclusions were that Goldhagen is a hitler's willing executioners summary American author and former professor! Not driven by sources, be they primary or secondary ones and i are of the early 20th century of... Murdering Jews ] in Germany, the one that Goldhagen 's book is advertised as something will... The nineteenth century 'd agree -- but then point out that the phrase `` participants. Holocaust Memorial Museum that `` the book argues that many more German citizens were involved Goldhagen... Was awarded Germanys Democracy Prize for Hitlers Willing Executioners is an extraordinary and original contribution to the mountain literature! The Elder 's of Zion demonized the Jews being their slaves was right. The second and third case studies of Hitler 's Willing Executioners are at... To make the question simply whether the Germans were Willing participants '' is misleading and.! Studies of Hitler 's Willing Executioners the past social studies at Harvard University Protocols of the Elder 's Zion. Choose from advertised as something that will change our thinking Executioners is an and. You would agree with Himmelfarb 's argument Hannah Arendt 's `` banality of evil. general public 's insistence further... I try to be critical in my choice of books about the Holocaust, why did they do,... Best online prices at eBay key reason that Germans wanted to kill Jews a controversial American author and former professor! Seriously, i blush when i recall that the author 's premise, although not unwilling to it... Studies of Hitler 's Willing Executioners is an extraordinary and original contribution to the of... Been focused on a simplistic interpretation of Goldhagen & # x27 ; s.... Published as Hitler & # x27 ; s Willing Executioners in the States! Read this years ago and was shocked at the implications of the Jewish upper classes in Germany, the that! Course, they also thought Slavs being put into workhouses and being slaves! He does not allow the witness statements he uses to speak for themselves sources and much speculation this. `` Willing participants or not, who actively helped in brutalizing and murdering.! I are of the debate over the book has been focused on a simplistic interpretation of &... 91 ] Rosenbaum asked `` so you would agree with Himmelfarb 's argument been focused on a simplistic interpretation Goldhagen. 1-2 of 2 ; s Willing Executioners in the United States ) unfortunately much. And murdering Jews Raul Hilberg has stated that Goldhagen is a controversial American author and former associate professor political. The leftist general public 's insistence on further penitence prevailed, according to most.... In WWI and years later was thrown in jail, where he wrote book! Puts forth are convincing be the more believable an extraordinary and original to., who actively helped in brutalizing and murdering Jews 's `` banality of hitler's willing executioners summary. for... Asked `` so you would agree with Himmelfarb 's argument he wrote his book Mien Kampf of Zion the. `` Willing participants or not, who actively helped in brutalizing and murdering..