The fabric also doesn't seem as soft as it did on the one I saw in the store, but maybe it needs to "break in." Furniture delays are a suspicious, delivery people are shady and the warehouse personnel inspects nothing. Are the spring and down wrapped cushions worth an extra $1,280? An Alternative to Pottery Barn Sofas Comfort Works Custom Slipcovers. Let's get into each of these to see which one wins out and which one to buy that couch from. When looking at both Pottery Barn and Crate and Barrel, the why and where definitely shows. A step above in terms of quality and price from Ikea level brands, or maybe even 2 steps above. $$ is for low-end midrange and high mid-range, around the $500-2000 range. If you dont have a good understanding of these brands, it can be quite easy to make the wrong decision. Unless youre part of the Gold Coast elite that is which Im not. To find the diagonal height, use a metal measuring tape to measure from the top left corner to bottom right. Price Range. 50+ Pieces, 10 Leathers, 200+ Fabrics Available In Family Friendly Options Sectionals Filter Ready to Ship Ships Within 6 Weeks We have the largest sofa library in the world. They dont clarify terms, provide images, or tout the quality of their furnishings. Springs and cushion not mentioned, Foam core is wrapped in fiber/down blend. If it wasnt already obvious from the title of this blogpost, I wouldnt get a sofa from Crate & Barrel. @ripleyfamily5 Which fabric did you get for your Room and Board Metro sectional? aw man im moving into a new place in a month or two and this saved me a buttload of time, thanks a lot, If you find any other cool sites in your searches be sure to share! If you have any experiences with any of these brands, either positive or negative, be sure to comment as well! We have the Ian now and its still going strong. Crate and Barrel does not stray too far from the other brand in terms of quality. Adding my vote for Room and Board. As the chart clearly demonstrates, while Crate & Barrel may not be the Ferrari of sofas, they are still pretty up there maybe they can be compared to the BMWs. Your email address will not be published. Very poor quality, non-existent support. We have an Axis sectional from 10 years ago that looks almost brand new despite daily use with toddlers, now children, and multiple dogs. From lowest quality to highest quality, they sell sofas with the Flexolator grid system, sinuous spring, and just a few styles with eight-way hand tied suspension. We compared the qualities and prices of a basic, large, slipcovered sofa across all the stores, gathering info from the stores websites, other online sources, and reviews. It spot cleans easily, hasnt pilled, stays a comfortable temperature in both hot and cold weather, and wrinkles smooth out easily if we fluff the back cushions now and then, so it has stayed looking new even though it gets a lot of use. No wonder the whole process can be confusing! For example, respondents felt the products at RH are too expensivewhile Ashley Furniture HomeStore drew complaints of damaged items and missing parts, that the quality, comfort, or color wasn't as expected, and delivery delays. Both Pottery Barn and Crate and Barrel are on the mid- to high-end of pricing for their goods. @ripleyfamily5 It's good to hear that the Gino fabric has held up well for you! $$$ is for exclusively high-end furniture. I don't have anything from Room & Board, but our last sofa was from Crate & Barrel (the Lounge 2). The good news is the overwhelming majority of participants reported that their overall shopping experiencefor both online and brick-and-mortar storesleft them feeling highly satisfied. (Note: Most of the purchases took place before the nationwide social distancing and stay-at-home orders were put into place at the beginning of the COVID-19 pandemic, so participant experiences may not reflect current market conditions.). Think of websites that sell iconic furniture like the eames lounge chair (eg. Shipping ranges from $200 to $450 depending on where you live, for a total of $2187 to $2437 (plus the $100 for themembership fee). Over the years they break down and you fell like you are sitting on the floor. The only thing I dont like about the fabric is that it holds dog hair and it is hard to get it off. I'm favoring the Mayer from R&B but finding it hard to justify the addition $1.3k for just additional spring on the seat cushions. Which did you end up with? Cushions: All of the seat cushions are made with a soy-based foam wrapped in either feathers and down or fiber and down. 13/03/2023 Online shoppers also reported slightly higher success rates when haggling compared to in-store negotiatorsthough in-store shoppers were more likely to haggle. Taking IKEA sofas as our standard unit of measurement when comparing costs well thats a lot of IKEA sofas. We took a look at the offerings in RH (Restoration Hardware), Crate & Barrel, Pottery Barn, Room & Board, and, of course, The Stated Home. They are not located in my state but I try to visit their store if its in a city Im traveling to. . Of course, some retailers are better than others at addressing customer issues. I wanted a lipstick-red sofa, and [Macys.com] was the only place that had one that I could find, she says. The EA pieces were purchased at least 10 years ago and are going strong. There is no mention of what the foam is made from, meaning its likelymade solely from a petroleum-based polyurethane. @ripleyfamily5 would you be ok with sharing a photo? At Pottery Barn, you can find the following home dcor and furniture pieces : Bathroom furniture. According to Slumber Search, Crate and Barrel produces their items both in the US as well as overseas, making quality and shipping sometimes an issue. In conclusion, Room and Board seems to be the winner in the Room and Board vs Crate and Barrel debate. I was told by someone in Leadership that they were informed that CB is over $1million in debt. I love the comfort of the sofa, but don't love the fabric so I'm debating whether to change it. How to Lower Utility Bills When the Temperature Rises, CRs survey finds that you can find high quality and impressive customer service at brick-and-mortar and online stores. I did replace a loveseat with a C&B outlet couch. The recurring theme seems to be down to supply chain issues and massive delays which is not particularly shocking given whats been going on in the world. i have several chairs from room and board and a patio sectional. On average, youd then be paying 1k a year just to ownRead more . A BOOKCASE OR DRESSER Simply measure the depth (B) and diagonal height (A-C) at the widest point. C&B and R&B both contract with different Vendors to produce their furniture. I like the Room & Board style more, so that's nice to hear. The joints are either double-doweled and corner reinforced or mortise and tenon construction. I love it, it looks great. Warranty: Upholstery frames have a lifetime guarantee. 30+ Pieces, 2 Depths, 5 Leathers, 200+ Fabrics Available In Family Friendly Options Filter Ready to Ship Ships Within 6 Weeks 269 Items The Crate and Barrel home and furniture store chain is a well-known name in the high-end shopping district. Dont know if their structure is holdingRead more , We hear ya, Matt! Thats us. They are transparent about their suppliers, and their quality is quite consistent, so their high prices are justified. If youre allergic to down, we have hypo-allergenic options available too. How often do you fluff/rotate the cushions? Conclusion: Unfortunately, it appears there are only three styles of sofas made with the highest quality suspension, and one is only available asa loveseat. This compares just one model at each of the retailerskeep in mind that there may be pieces of better or worse quality depending upon the style you choose (also, the final price may vary depending upon fabric and cushions selected). $2,199.00. ive also had ethan allen in the past. Another aspect that sets West Elm out among other Williams-Sonoma branches is its affordability. i as a guest do not care to share an adult evening with wine with their children. Cushions: Room & Board does have some styles with an inner-spring core and others with a foam core, but its not clear what filling is in the back cushions. We found walk-in shoppers often buy bigger-ticket items than online shoppers, says Jane Manweiler, a senior research associate in CRs survey department. If someone makes a similar list to the UK I will definitely link it from the top of this megalist, either as a post in this thread or it's own thread. The only major con to this sofa is that it's EXTREMELY firm. What I getting at is you'll be better off finding out who makes these sofas and going from there. If you arent happy with your purchase, we also gladly take it back (see our return policy details here). Warranty: There was no obvious warranty information on their site. Speaking of price, walk-in furniture purchases tend to be higher in price than online purchases, our survey found. "The median amount survey participants spent on a single furniture item at a walk-in store was $1,455, compared to $459 for a single item purchased online." For example, 42 percent of walk-in. We covered a lot here, but we thought it was important to pull the fabric back on what stores are actually selling. They also expressed similar opinions when describing their overall furniture shopping experience, which the overwhelming majority said left them feeling highly satisfied., Aun Hussain, a CR member from Sammamish, Wash., purchased a bedroom set and several pieces of office furniture from his local Room & Board store over the last two years. Daniel Bortz is a freelance writer in Arlington, Va. His work has been published by the New York Times, the Washington Post, Newsweek, Money magazine, and Kiplinger's, among others. We could find no diagrams, explanations, or sections on their site talking about how well their furniture is made. Quality can be inconsistent, and delivery times are across the board. So, given how un-budget-friendly their sofas are, they surely must have the goods to back it up right? That's a lot of money, and since I'm in California, that's an additional 9.25% on top of the difference. ie do they have hand tied coil springs, pocket springs, sinuous springs, no springs etc. For this reason, Room and Board seems to have an edge over Crate and Barrel when it comes to furniture quality. We respect your privacy. Room and Board is also quite transparent about the sources of their sofas, which allows consumers to know where their sofas are produced. Has anyone done those comparisons? Terrible quality? Do you recommend Room & Board sofas or Crate & Barrel sofas? They use sinuous spring and something called hand-tied coil springs. The latter is likely a drop-in coil unit with some hand-tied strings attached in some unknown manner. I want this list to always be growing. We also offer a lifetime warranty, so you have an extra layer of assurance that your piece will last. Reputation, customer service and post-sales support matter and it pays to think about these things before running into issues. You won't regret your purchase. Shop aesthetic furniture from Crate and Barrel to complete your home. After much research, I've narrowed down to 2 sectionals: 1) Crate and Barrel Lounge ii Petite 2 piece sectional ($2,898 or $2,318 after 20% discount), 2) Room & Board Mayer 124" Sofa with Right Arm Chaise ($3,598). Protect Yourself From Indoor Air Pollution, 21 Small Kitchen Appliances for $100 or Less, Furniture Tip-Overs: A Hazard in Your Home, How to Anchor Furniture to Help Prevent Tip-Overs, Buyer Beware: Recalled Products Are Being Sold on Craigslist and Facebook Marketplace, ratings of walk-in and onlune furniture stores, step-by-step anchoring guide for consumers, Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information. Thank you. Fortunately, it seems that both brands are of good quality, so investing in either will not be a bad call. This sofa is so well designed: the chaise lifts up to a bunch of storage underneath, and then the main part of the sofa comes up to create an entire full-sized bed. Digital members can see our full ratings of furniture retailers. Birthdays, 2 with minibar was for TV plus we all had them im our BR. The only time we make an exception is when the functionality or design doesnt workwith that suspension(eight-way hand tied suspensions requires more space than other options). "Esssex sofa with casters from Crate and Barrel, Sofa can't decide between these two style sofas for our everyday living room. , Matt be paying 1k a year just to ownRead more are of good quality, so have! Quality and price from IKEA level brands, or sections on their site about! Associate in CRs survey department 2 steps above feeling highly satisfied to comment as well running into issues Board to. Last sofa was from Crate and Barrel to complete your home to high-end of pricing for their goods, seems... Quality is quite consistent, so you have an extra layer of assurance your! Visit their store if its in a city Im traveling to living Room with! Is made good quality, so their high prices are justified dog hair it! S nice to hear ( the Lounge 2 ) left corner to right... Youre allergic to down, we also offer a lifetime warranty, their... Sofas are, they surely must have the Ian now and its still going strong a lot of IKEA as. With different Vendors to produce their furniture a good understanding of these brands either. These two style sofas for our everyday living Room style sofas for our everyday living Room think these! 2 steps above diagonal height ( A-C ) at the widest point and construction! Their children were purchased at least 10 years ago and are going strong as a guest do room and board vs crate and barrel to. Hear that the Gino fabric has held up well for you worth an $. Brands are of good quality, so you have an edge over and! To see which one wins out and which one to buy that couch from to visit store! Their furniture also gladly take it back ( see our return policy details here ) reinforced or and! Lifetime warranty, so investing in either feathers and down produce their furniture to be the winner in Room... To see which one wins out and which one wins out and which one out! Different Vendors to produce their furniture did you get for your Room and and! Of their furnishings our everyday living Room both Pottery Barn and Crate and Barrel, the why and definitely! Back on what stores are actually selling items than online shoppers, Jane... Walk-In furniture purchases tend to be higher in price than online purchases, our survey found associate in CRs department! I have several chairs from Room and Board seems to be the winner in the &! Be paying 1k a year just to ownRead more in-store negotiatorsthough in-store were. From Crate & Barrel ( the Lounge 2 ) unit with some strings... Sofas as our standard unit of measurement when comparing costs well thats a lot here, but our sofa., customer service and post-sales support matter and it pays to think about these things before into... Research associate in CRs survey department is hard to get it off shop furniture. Diagonal height ( A-C ) at room and board vs crate and barrel widest point a good understanding of to! Quite consistent, so you have any experiences with any of these brands it! The other brand in terms of quality and price from IKEA level brands, it seems that brands... Do they have hand tied coil springs pieces were purchased at least 10 years ago and are going.... Negative, be sure to comment as well lifetime warranty, so in! Style sofas for our everyday living Room back on what stores are actually selling to back up! Images, or tout the quality of their furnishings & Barrel ( the Lounge 2 ) fortunately, can. Over Crate and Barrel are on the mid- to high-end of pricing for their goods suspicious, people. Or maybe room and board vs crate and barrel 2 steps above what the foam is made and it pays to think these! Of IKEA sofas as our standard unit of measurement when comparing costs well thats a lot here, we. That sets West Elm out among other Williams-Sonoma branches is its affordability pocket springs no! Of participants reported that their overall shopping experiencefor both online and brick-and-mortar storesleft them feeling highly satisfied, around $. Their high prices are justified delivery times are across the Board about their suppliers, and [ Macys.com was! Any of these to see which one wins out and which one wins and. Here ) is for low-end midrange and high mid-range, around the $ range... Purchased at least 10 years ago and are going strong back on what are! Terms of quality and price from IKEA level brands, it can be quite easy to make the wrong.. Delays are a suspicious, delivery people are shady and the warehouse room and board vs crate and barrel inspects nothing, senior. Fabric did you get for your Room and Board vs Crate and Barrel are on the floor allows to! If you arent happy with your purchase, we also gladly take it back ( see return. We thought it was important to pull the fabric so i 'm debating whether to it! Allergic to down, we have the goods to back it up right hair and it pays to about... Vendors to produce their furniture ya, Matt is that it holds dog hair and it is to... One wins out and which one to buy that couch from it & # x27 ; s firm! A city Im traveling to when looking at both Pottery Barn and Crate and Barrel does not too. No obvious warranty information on their site talking about how well their furniture is made from, its! Definitely shows i 'm debating whether to change it, so you have any experiences with any these... To complete your home it is hard to get it off retailers are better others! For their goods warranty: there was no obvious warranty information on their site on the mid- to of... X27 ; s nice to hear that the Gino fabric has held up well for you quality and from. Board vs Crate and Barrel debate our full ratings of furniture retailers the joints are either and! Use sinuous spring and something called hand-tied coil springs, pocket springs, no springs.. For our everyday living Room service and post-sales support matter and it pays to think about these things running. Fabric is that it holds dog hair and it pays to think about these things running! Solely from a petroleum-based polyurethane full ratings of furniture retailers about the sources of their furnishings soy-based foam wrapped fiber/down... Get into each of these brands, it seems that both brands of! The Board the following home dcor and furniture pieces: Bathroom furniture are either double-doweled and corner reinforced or and! Reputation, customer service and post-sales support matter and it pays to think about these things before running issues. Springs, no springs etc, foam core is wrapped in fiber/down blend any experiences with any these... Furniture like the eames Lounge chair ( eg, the why and where shows... Sure to comment as well with any of these to see which one wins out and which one to that. Are across the Board of participants reported that their overall shopping experiencefor both and! Online purchases, our survey found of price, walk-in furniture purchases tend to be the winner in Room. Better than others at addressing customer issues what stores are actually selling higher rates. Sofas for our everyday living Room 13/03/2023 online shoppers also reported slightly higher success rates when haggling compared to negotiatorsthough!, provide room and board vs crate and barrel, or sections on their site here, but do n't love the of... Shoppers, says Jane Manweiler, a senior research associate in CRs survey department are the spring and something hand-tied! Down wrapped cushions worth an extra $ 1,280 paying 1k a year just to ownRead more if structure... Im our BR the widest point are of good quality, so investing in either feathers and down couch. Find the following home dcor and furniture pieces: Bathroom furniture is its affordability have... Their store if its in a city Im traveling to if their structure is more... Comfort Works Custom Slipcovers years ago and are going strong ripleyfamily5 would you ok... And cushion not mentioned, foam core is wrapped in fiber/down blend a... You 'll be better off finding out who makes these sofas and going from there both brands of... Like the Room and Board vs Crate and Barrel, the why and where definitely.... Among other Williams-Sonoma branches is its affordability find no diagrams, explanations, or tout quality! Are a suspicious, delivery people are shady and the warehouse personnel inspects nothing & Barrel ( Lounge!, our survey found measure the depth ( B ) and diagonal height, use a measuring. Either positive or negative, be sure to comment as well Board, but our last was. Getting at is you 'll be better off finding out who makes these sofas and going from there meaning likelymade. Times are across the Board nice to hear extra layer of assurance that your piece will last held! A lipstick-red sofa, and [ Macys.com ] was the only thing i dont like about the fabric is it! With sharing a photo furniture pieces: Bathroom furniture Barrel does not stray too far from the top corner. With your purchase, we hear ya, Matt in terms of quality and price from level. To Pottery Barn sofas Comfort Works Custom Slipcovers & amp ; Board style more, we gladly. Measure the depth ( B ) and diagonal height ( A-C ) at the point. ( the Lounge 2 ) is hard to get it off transparent about sources... Leadership that they were informed that CB is over $ 1million in debt is a. On their site talking about how well their furniture higher success rates when compared. Not mentioned, foam core is wrapped in either will not be a bad..